What if the ultimate mascara for long, thick, lush lashes was actually… two mascaras? (Or more!) That’s the theory behind mascara cocktailing, the latest beauty trend taking over TikTok.

The method is exactly what it sounds like: mix a few different mascaras together like a cocktail (or a mocktail, of course) to create a custom lash look. Layering two mascaras isn’t necessarily a new technique; Makeup artists and beauty fans have been crafting their perfect makeup recipes for years, pairing a volumizing formula with a lengthening formula or adding a few coats of a thickening formula for super-full false lashes. The key is to layer two mascaras with different results to get the look you want, like long and curled or thick and voluminous. TikTok users have brought the method to the masses with videos showing the almost magical effects of mascara cocktailing and their top mascara picks to get the look.

TikToker katiehub.org has makeup fans buzzing with her fan-favorite combination of two Essence mascaras for length and volume Lash Princess Curl Mascara and the volume formation Double Trouble Mascara, which has a double shaft for extreme definition and length. Her final result? Long, elaborate eyelashes that were almost twice the size of her bare eyelashes! Even actor and Honest Beauty founder Jessica Alba has tapped into the cocktail trend, Share multiple videos of her favorite masks to merge.

Want to try your hand (or your lashes?) at mascara cocktailing? It’s a super easy trend to do at home if you have a few mascaras in your makeup bag, especially if you don’t like one on your own; When combined with another formula, it just might make mascara magic! TikTokers especially love the Essence formulas and CoverGirl’s Clump Crusher Mascara. TikTok user akaskinbasics is a huge fan of the CoverGirl, and makeup.com’s cat line vape loves Lancôme. TikToker petrah reed reef use various formulas to fake the look of eyelash extensions. You may have to mix and match a few different formulas to find the one that works best for you and your lashes, but when you see your reflection in the mirror, you will know when you’ve landed on the most delicious mascara cocktail.

Scroll on to see some of TikTok and teenage Fashion editors’ favorite mascaras for all your cocktail needs.

L’Oréal Telescopic Original Mascara

This post was originally published in teenage Fashion.