Forget dresses over jeans, Blake Lively is making the case for pants over pants.

It would be more accurate to say that the It ends with us costume department is behind the controversial look. Lively was photographed with new set photos from the film adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s best-selling novel of the same name. On May 25, Lively and her freshly styled red hair were spotted in Hoboken, New Jersey wearing a pair of low-rise patterned khaki pants over what appeared to be blue patchwork boxers or some other pair of pants altogether.

The top half of Lively’s fit also had a lot going on, with a ribbed navy crop top underneath a yellow, blue and white button-down shirt and matching lemon leather trench. Let’s just say there was nothing subtle about this Lily Bloom look—even her shoes featured standout bronze boots!

While your favorite high school art teacher will definitely find something to love among this mix of patterns and textures, many fans were confused by this appearanceas well as other ensembles Lively was spotted on set wear the past few days. “Each photo released just gets worse and worse,” one commenter wrote under a TikTok videos of the ensemble, while another wrote: “It feels like a joke now.”

Lily Bloom’s wardrobe is far from the only controversy to plague It ends with us, including complaints from fans that Blake Lively is “too old” to play the book’s 23-year-old protagonist (she’s 35). Meanwhile, one fan of the book thought this outfit fit Lily’s vibe perfectly, saying: “The way it is EXACTLY how Lily would dress… Like you know the style of her flower shop?”